🎯 What is the SCA?
The Simulated Consultation Assessment (SCA) is a practical exam that tests your ability to manage consultations in a realistic GP setting. You'll be presented with simulated patients and have 12 minutes per case to demonstrate your clinical reasoning, communication skills, and management abilities.
Exam Structure
⏱️
Duration
12 minutes per case
🕐
Total Time
~3 hours (with breaks)
🎭
Actors
Trained simulated patients
The 12-Minute Consultation Framework
Each consultation is 12 minutes. Here's how to structure your time effectively:
0-1 min
Opening & Verification
- Introductions
- Patient verification
- Golden minute (let patient speak)
2-6 min
Data Gathering & ICE
- History taking
- Ideas, Concerns, Expectations
- Relevant past history
- Social context
7-11 min
Explanation & Options
- Explain diagnosis
- Link problems to symptoms
- Provide management options
- Shared decision-making
11-12 min
Closing & Safety
- Agree plan together
- Arrange follow-up
- Safety netting
- Closing remarks
Marking Domains
The SCA is marked across three domains. Domain 2 (Clinical Management) is weighted 1.5x in the final score.
Domain 1: Data Gathering & Interpretation
- History taking
- Physical examination (where appropriate)
- Interpretation of findings
- Clinical reasoning
Domain 2: Clinical Management (Weighted 1.5x)
- Diagnosis and differentials
- Management plan
- Prescribing (if appropriate)
- Safety netting
- Follow-up arrangements
This domain counts 50% more than the others!
Domain 3: Interpersonal Skills
- Communication
- Empathy
- Patient-centred care
- Professionalism
Grading System
Each domain is scored 0-4 points. Domain 2 (Clinical Management) is weighted 1.5x. Total possible: 10.5 points.
4
Clear Pass
Score >9/10.5 - Excellent performance across all domains
3
Pass
Score 6-9/10.5 - Good performance, meets standard
2
Fail
Score 3-6/10.5 - Below standard, needs improvement
1
Clear Fail
Score <3/10.5 - Significant concerns, requires focused practice
3-4 Month Preparation Strategy
A structured approach to SCA preparation. Adjust the timeline based on your exam date, but aim for consistency and progressive skill building.
Month 1: Foundation & Breadth
Goal: Build a solid foundation, establish routine, and get comfortable with the consultation format. Focus on breadth over depth.
Week 1-2: Getting the Feel
- Practice untimed consultations: Do 2-3 cases per week without time pressure - focus on structure and flow
- Learn consultation models: Familiarize yourself with different frameworks (Calgary-Cambridge, Pendleton, etc.)
- Watch example consultations: Observe good practice - notice how experienced GPs structure their time
- Start a consultation log: Note what works, what doesn't, areas to improve
- Establish routine: Set aside dedicated time each week for SCA practice - consistency is key
Week 3-4: Clinical Topics Revision
- Review common presentations: Cover breadth of conditions (respiratory, cardiovascular, mental health, women's health, paediatrics)
- Focus on top 20 conditions: Asthma, COPD, hypertension, diabetes, depression, anxiety, UTI, back pain, etc.
- NICE guidelines: Know the key pathways for common conditions - don't memorize, understand the logic
- Differential diagnoses: Practice thinking "what else could this be?" for each presentation
- Safety netting: Learn red flags and when to refer urgently vs. routine
- Practice cases: Do 3-4 cases per week, still untimed, focusing on clinical knowledge application
💡 Month 1 Tip: Don't worry about speed yet. Focus on getting comfortable with the consultation structure and building your clinical knowledge base. Quality over quantity.
Month 2: Explanations & Practice Tools
Goal: Master explanations, integrate practice tools, and start working under time pressure.
Week 5-6: Mastering Explanations
- Practice 2-minute explanations: Use the 2-minute diagnosis timer - explain a condition clearly and concisely
- Structure your explanations: What is it? Why do you think it's this? What are the options? What do you recommend?
- Link problems to symptoms: Practice connecting the diagnosis back to what the patient told you
- Use simple language: Avoid jargon - explain as if to a friend, not a medical student
- Practice with different conditions: Explain asthma, depression, hypertension, UTI - get comfortable with common ones
- Record yourself: Listen back - are you clear? Do you sound confident? Are you linking back to symptoms?
Week 7-8: Practice Tools Integration
- 3-minute primer exercises: Practice reading case notes and formulating your approach in 3 minutes
- Use the 2-minute diagnosis timer: Regular practice - aim for 5-10 explanations per week
- Timed consultations: Start timing yourself - aim for 12 minutes total, but don't panic if you go over initially
- Practice with different case types: Acute, chronic, mental health, complex - get exposure to variety
- Self-assessment: After each practice case, use the self-assessment tool - be honest about your performance
- Focus on Domain 2: Remember it's weighted 1.5x - practice clear management plans, safety netting, follow-up
💡 Month 2 Tip: Explanations are where many trainees struggle. Practice until you can explain any common condition clearly in 2 minutes. The 2-minute timer and 3-minute primer are your best friends - use them regularly.
Month 3: Time Management & Fine-Tuning
Goal: Master time management in exam conditions. Fine-tune consultation skills and learn to use your framework flexibly to enhance, not constrain, your consultations.
Week 9-10: Time Management in Exam Setting
Strict 12-Minute Practice:
- Every consultation timed: Use a visible timer - practice with the same pressure you'll feel in the exam
- No exceptions: If you go over 12 minutes, stop and reflect - what went wrong? What can you cut?
- Practice exam conditions: Do 2-3 full mock exams (12 cases) with breaks between - simulate the real thing
- Time awareness without clock-watching: Develop internal sense of time - check clock at key points (5 min, 9 min, 11 min)
Time Management Strategies:
- 0-1 min opening: Keep it brief - "Hello, I'm Dr X. How can I help?" Then let them speak. Don't overthink the introduction.
- 2-6 min data gathering: Use open questions first, then narrow. If patient is verbose, gently redirect: "That's helpful, can I ask about..."
- 7-11 min explanation: This is where time often runs out. Practice concise explanations - 2-3 minutes max. If you're at 9 minutes and haven't explained, you're behind.
- 11-12 min closing: Always leave 1 minute for safety netting and follow-up - this is non-negotiable. If you're at 11 minutes and still explaining, wrap it up quickly.
Identify Your Time-Wasters:
- History taking too long? Practice asking focused questions. Learn to recognize when you have enough information.
- Examination taking too long? Only examine what's relevant. Practice quick, focused examinations.
- Explanation too long? Use the 2-minute timer religiously. Practice explaining common conditions in 90 seconds.
- Getting stuck on one thing? Learn to move on. If you can't get a clear answer after 2-3 attempts, make a reasonable assumption and proceed.
Practical Time Management Tips:
- Set mental checkpoints: At 5 minutes, you should be gathering history. At 9 minutes, you should be explaining. At 11 minutes, you should be closing.
- Learn to cut gracefully: "I can see this is important to you, but we have limited time. Can we focus on the main concern today?"
- Practice with a timer visible: Get comfortable checking the time without panicking
- Build in buffer time: Aim to finish at 11.5 minutes - gives you 30 seconds if something unexpected happens
Week 11-12: Fine-Tuning Consultation Skills
Using Your Framework Flexibly:
The 0-1, 2-6, 7-11, 11-12 framework is a guide, not a straitjacket. Learn to adapt it:
- Simple cases: You might finish data gathering by 4 minutes - use the extra time for thorough explanation and shared decision-making
- Complex cases: You might need 7 minutes for history - that's okay, but you'll need to be more efficient in explanation
- Emotional cases: Patient crying at 3 minutes? Take 30 seconds to acknowledge it - it's worth it. Adjust your timeline accordingly
- Routine cases: If it's straightforward (e.g., repeat prescription), you can move through faster - use saved time for health promotion
Fine-Tuning Specific Skills:
- History-taking efficiency: Practice asking questions that get you multiple pieces of information at once: "Tell me about the pain - when did it start, what makes it better or worse?"
- ICE integration: Don't ask "What are your ideas?" as a separate question - weave it in: "What do you think might be causing this?" during history
- Explanation clarity: Practice linking back: "You mentioned the pain started after lifting - that's likely why your back is sore. Here's what's happening..."
- Safety netting precision: Be specific: "If the pain gets worse, or you develop numbness in your leg, come back immediately" - not just "come back if it gets worse"
- Follow-up clarity: Be explicit: "I'd like to see you in 2 weeks to see how the medication is working. Book an appointment, or come back sooner if needed."
Addressing Weak Areas:
- Review self-assessments: Look at your last 10 practice cases - where do you consistently score 2 or below?
- Domain 1 weak? Practice focused history-taking. Learn to recognize red flags quickly. Practice interpreting findings.
- Domain 2 weak? Focus on management plans. Practice clear, logical plans. Always include safety netting. Know when to refer.
- Domain 3 weak? Work on rapport. Practice empathy statements. Improve your explanation style. Practice shared decision-making.
- Get targeted feedback: Practice with a trainer or colleague - ask them to focus on your weak domain
Advanced Consultation Techniques:
- Handling difficult patients: Practice with cases involving anger, anxiety, or challenging personalities. Stay calm, acknowledge emotions, redirect professionally
- Breaking bad news: Practice the SPIKES framework. Be clear, empathetic, check understanding, offer support
- Managing uncertainty: Practice explaining when you're not sure: "I think this is most likely X, but we need to watch for Y. Here's what we'll do..."
- Dealing with multiple problems: Learn to prioritize: "I can see you have several concerns. Let's start with the most urgent one today, and we can address the others in follow-up."
- Cultural sensitivity: Practice consultations that require understanding different perspectives, beliefs, or communication styles
💡 Month 3 Key Principles:
- Time management is a skill: It improves with practice. Don't panic if you're still going over time - identify the problem and fix it
- Framework as a tool: Use the timing framework to guide you, not constrain you. Adapt it to each case
- Quality within time: Speed shouldn't compromise quality. Practice until you can do both
- Consistency: By the end of Month 3, you should be consistently completing consultations within 12 minutes while maintaining quality
- Know your limits: If you're consistently struggling with time or quality, consider extending your preparation or getting additional support
Month 4: Exam Readiness
Goal: Peak performance. Build confidence and exam technique.
Week 13-14: Full Mock Exams
- Full mock exams: Do 2-3 complete exams (12 cases) under strict exam conditions
- Review every case: After each mock, review what went well and what didn't
- Practice exam day routine: Same time of day, same preparation - build familiarity
- Mental preparation: Visualize exam day, practice staying calm under pressure
Week 15-16: Final Polish
- Light practice: Maintain skills but avoid burnout - 1-2 cases per week
- Review key guidelines: Quick revision of NICE pathways for common conditions
- Practice explanations: Keep the 2-minute timer sharp
- Rest: Don't practice the day before the exam - rest is part of preparation
💡 Month 4 Tip: You should be consistently scoring passes or clear passes in mocks. If not, consider postponing - it's better to take it when ready. Confidence is key.
General Preparation Tips
- Consistency beats intensity: Regular practice (3-4 cases per week) is better than cramming
- Use the tools: The 2-minute diagnosis timer and 3-minute primer are designed to help - use them regularly
- Self-assessment is key: Be honest about your performance - it's the only way to improve
- Focus on Domain 2: Remember it's weighted 1.5x - strong management plans and safety netting are essential
- Practice variety: Don't just practice easy cases - challenge yourself with complex presentations
- Get feedback: Practice with colleagues or trainers - external perspective is invaluable
- Stay calm: The SCA tests real GP skills - if you're a good GP trainee, you can pass this exam